BIRTHDAY CAKE PROTEIN COOKIES

November 11, 2015

BIRTHDAY CAKE PROTEIN COOKIES

Cookies for breakfast? Shame on me. Well, not just any cookies… unbelievably delicious, almost sugar free Birthday Cake Protein Cookies! These are seriously wonderful. This recipe recently got a makeover with NEW photos and one small tweak! The original recipe called for a whole teaspoon of butter extract and in remaking them it tasted like a bit too much.

Anyway, these birthday cake protein cookies make the perfect post-workout or anytime snack at just 78 calories per cookie, and they taste so darn good! Think of those sugar cookies you get at the grocery store, soft yet just enough “chewiness” to feel like a cookie (versus a puffy protein “cloud”). The flavor is a rich, buttery vanilla with plenty of sprinkles!

Of course, you could leave out the sprinkles for a legit protein sugar cookie with even lower carbs! But, sprinkles are fun… so… if you’re feeling festive, I highly recommend them.

What kind of protein powder works best for baking?

The protein powder I used in this recipe is Quest Protein Powder in Vanilla Milkshake. Any whey protein should work in this recipe, but some work better than others. Whey blends combining whey isolate, casein, and milk protein work best for baking! Whey concentrate would be my second choice. Whey isolates are the absolute worst for baking! They tend to make baked goods spongey and dry because they have zero fat. This said after 5 years of baking with various whey protein brands!

Sweetener substitutions

To add sweetness without the sugar, I used an organic, calorie-free stevia-erythritol blend that’s twice as sweet as sugar. You can use any sweetener you like! Keep in mind, if using erythritol, monk fruit, baking stevia or another sweetener that measures 1-to-1 like sugar, you’ll need twice as much (half a cup). Feel free to use coconut sugar or raw sugar but this will increase the calories and sugar quite a bit.

Other substitutions

To keep the carbs low, I used coconut flour. If you choose to substitute the coconut flour with some other flour, you will want to start with twice as much since coconut flour absorbs so much moisture.

The only other ingredients in these Birthday Cake Protein Cookies are baking soda, salt, Greek yogurt, cashew butter, egg whites, vanilla extract, and natural sprinkles. Like I said, you should be able to swap out the egg whites and Greek yogurt for vegan egg replacer and dairy-free yogurt. The cashew butter can be swapped for sunflower seed butter, but most other nut butters are not neutral-tasting or smooth enough for these cookies.

You can get natural sprinkles without artificial colors on Amazon, or just use standard sprinkles if that’s all you have, or leave them out.

Here’s the printable recipe for these Birthday Cake Protein Cookies! I hope you’ll rate and comment below if you try them 🙂

This post contains affiliate links.

Birthday Cake Protein Cookies

These birthday cake protein cookies are soft, tender, and full of fun sprinkles. Low in sugar and high in protein, perfect healthy treat.
Course Dessert
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Servings 12 cookies
Calories 78kcal

Ingredients

  • 80 g vanilla whey protein blend* I used Quest brand in Vanilla milkshake
  • 1/4 cup calorie-free sweetener* I used one that's twice as sweet as sugar
  • 1/4 cup coconut flour*
  • 1/2 tsp. baking soda
  • 1/4 tsp. salt optional
  • 1/2 cup nonfat plain greek yogurt*
  • 1/4 cup cashew butter*
  • 1/4 cup (2 large) egg whites*
  • 1 tsp. vanilla extract
  • 1/2 tsp. butter extract optional
  • 2 tsp. natural sprinkles* optional

*See blog post above for substitutions.

    Instructions

    • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F.
    • Whisk together dry ingredients (through salt) in a medium mixing bowl.
    • Add wet ingredients (through butter extract) and mix until no clumps remain.
    • Stir in sprinkles if desired (optional).
    • Place heaping tablespoons of cookie dough on a baking sheet lined with parchment or lightly coated with cooking spray.
    • Press flat slightly with wetted fingertips (batter will be sticky).
    • Bake for 10-12 minutes until cookies are golden brown underneath. Enjoy!

    Notes

    Calories (per cookie, including optional ingredients): 78kcal, Fat: 3.2g, Sat fat: 0.9g, Carbs: 4g, Fiber: 1g, Sugar: 1g, Protein: 8g, Sodium: 160mg




    Leave a comment

    Comments will be approved before showing up.


    Also in Blog

    SWEET POTATO COLLAGEN PROTEIN WAFFLES
    SWEET POTATO COLLAGEN PROTEIN WAFFLES

    November 23, 2022

    I love a good waffle and these Sweet Potato Collagen Protein Waffles did not disappoint! They've got a tender, moist texture thanks to the sweet potato and are also gluten-free, dairy-free, and low in sugar! I love these waffles topped with pomegranate, coconut yogurt, and maple syrup... but they're really a blank canvas for whatever you enjoy!

    View full article →

    SLOW COOKER WHITE CHICKEN CHILI
    SLOW COOKER WHITE CHICKEN CHILI

    November 17, 2022

    This healthy Slow Cooker White Chicken Chili is made with dried whole beans not canned! I also used raw chicken breasts - no more hunting for rotisserie chicken! All you have to do is layer everything in a crockpot or slow cooker, then leave overnight for the best white chicken chili the next day.

    View full article →

    PUMPKIN PIE PROTEIN TRUFFLES (VEGAN)
    PUMPKIN PIE PROTEIN TRUFFLES (VEGAN)

    October 21, 2022

    Pumpkin and white chocolate is one of my favorite fall flavor combos! These Pumpkin Pie Protein Truffles taste like pumpkin pie rolled into balls and smothered with rich white chocolate. They're also gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan, and easily made low carb and keto. So irresistible I've made two batches already! Literally cannot distinguish these from full sugar treats.

    View full article →

    Get my FREE meal prep guide!

    Get family-friendly recipes, nutrition tips and faith-based inspiration delivered straight to your inbox.