FROSTED PROTEIN SUGAR COOKIES

December 14, 2016

FROSTED PROTEIN SUGAR COOKIES

How about some frosted protein sugar cookies that taste like the real deal… with only ONE GRAM of sugar per cookie? Seems like an oxymoron doesn’t it: “a sugar-free sugar cookie”? Well, believe it! Each full-sized, soft-baked cookie is just 80 calories with 5 grams of protein and 3 grams net carbs. These aren’t exactly “low fat” at just under 5 grams per cookie, but then again, you shouldn’t be filling your macros with just cookies anyway 😉 Even still, you can easily fit in two or three of these “healthified” sugar cookies into a balanced meal plan. Did I mention they’re soft with just the right amount of “bite” and that frosting is to die for?

FROSTED PROTEIN SUGAR COOKIES

Protein powder substitutions

To up the protein in these beauties, I used Jamie Eason Lean Body for Her Whey in Natural Vanilla. Though you can use any whey blend or concentrate, using a brand with artificial flavors may alter the flavor, or even make them taste “fake.” That’s why I love Jamie’s all-natural line! I can feel good about what I’m putting into my body and her protein tastes awesome. Another note, most isolates will not work in this recipe – you’re better off with a whey blend or a whey concentrate.

FROSTED PROTEIN SUGAR COOKIES

Sweetener substitutions

For all that sugary goodness without the actual sugar, I used Pyure Organic Stevia Blend for the cookie dough and Swerve Confectioner’s Erythritol for the frosting. Both sweeteners are calorie-free, all-natural, and non-GMO. If you don’t have Pyure Organic Stevia Blend, you can use twice as much baking stevia, granulated erythritol, or granulated monk fruit.

While there aren’t a lot of suitable substitutes for the Swerve Confectioner’s Erythritol (besides powdered sugar), I have heard you can blend Truvia into a fine powder and use half as much. I haven’t tried it myself though! Definitely don’t use straight stevia or the frosting will taste very bitter. NOTE: I did not include the natural sugar alcohols from the erythritol in the carb count since they don’t provide energy or fiber.

FROSTED PROTEIN SUGAR COOKIES

Flour substitutions

To keep the carbs low, I went with Bob’s Red Mill coconut flour, but you can also substitute twice as much all-purpose flour, gluten-free baking blend, oat flour, or spelt flour. I’m sure you could even use almond flour but you’d probably need to use even more than twice as much (or use less water)… to get a workable dough.

FROSTED PROTEIN SUGAR COOKIES

Other ingredient substitutions

I used a combination of cashew butter, Smart Balance Omega 3 Buttery Spread, VitaFiber syrup, and water to moisten the dough and provide a soft yet chewy texture. You can try using all cashew butter in place of the buttery spread, but you might get a dryer cookie. You can also use unsalted butter in place of the buttery spread, but this will increase the fat content.

Finally, you can replace the VitaFiber syrup with any sticky syrup such as agave, brown rice syrup, honey, maple syrup, sugar free pancake syrup (or even water… they just won’t be as chewy).

FROSTED PROTEIN SUGAR COOKIES

Other frosting options

If you don’t want to use the buttercream frosting, try mixing together whipped cream cheese and sweetener or even protein powder and a small amount of unsweetened almond milk or cashew milk to increase the protein and lower the fat. I’ll leave that up to you! They’re absolutely scrumptious as is 😉

Here’s the recipe for these Frosted Protein Sugar Cookies! As always, I’d love your comments if you try them.

This post contains affiliate links.

Frosted Protein Sugar Cookies

These Frosted Protein Sugar Cookies are low-calorie, low sugar, and high in protein! Tender sugar cookies topped with sugar free buttercream frosting.
Course Dessert
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 8 minutes
Servings 12 cookies
Calories 73kcal

Ingredients

Cookies

  • 80 g vanilla whey blend or whey concentrate protein powder I used Lean Body for Her Whey in Natural Vanilla
  • 6 tbsp. coconut flour* or 3/4 cup all-purpose, gluten-free, or oat flour
  • 1/4 cup calorie-free sweetener* I used Pyure organic stevia blend
  • 1/4 tsp. salt optional
  • 1/4 tsp. baking soda
  • 2 tbsp. creamy cashew butter* or tahini
  • 2 tbsp. vegan buttery spread* or unsalted butter
  • 3 tbsp. water adjust as needed
  • 2 tbsp. (1 large) egg white
  • 1 tbsp. VitaFiber syrup* or brown rice syrup, maple syrup, sugar free pancake syrup
  • 1/2 tsp. pure vanilla extract

Frosting

  • 1/2 cup Swerve confectioner's erythritol* or powdered sugar
  • 1 tbsp. tapioca starch or cornstarch, potato starch
  • 2 tbsp. unsweetened almond milk* or milk of choice
  • 1 tbsp. vegan buttery spread* or unsalted butter

*See blog post for tips on substitutions.

    Instructions

    • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F.
    • Whisk together dry cookie ingredients (through baking soda) in a small mixing bowl.
    • Add wet ingredients (through vanilla extract) and mix until a dough forms.
    • Line a baking sheet with parchment paper or lightly spray with cooking spray.
    • Using a tablespoon, measure out dough and form into balls, placing roughly 2″ apart on sheet.
    • Press balls flat to roughly half an inch thick using the back of a spatula or your hand.
    • Bake for 8-10 minutes until edges are firm but center is still soft (cookies will set upon cooling). I flattened mine a little more fresh out of the oven with the back of a spatula.
    • While cookies cool, combine frosting ingredients in a separate mixing bowl until smooth.
    • Spread frosting over cookies and decorate with sprinkles if desired. Enjoy!
    • Cookies can be stored at room temperature for several days or frozen up to a month.

    Notes

    Calories (per cookie, with frosting): 81kcal, Fat: 4.8g, Sat fat: 1.6g, Carbs: 5g, Fiber: 2g, Sugar: 1g, Protein: 5g, Sodium: 144mg
    Calories (per cookie, without frosting): 73kcal, Fat: 4.0g, Sat fat: 1.4g, Carbs: 4g, Fiber: 2g, Sugar: 1g, Protein: 5g, Sodium: 135mg




    Leave a comment

    Comments will be approved before showing up.


    Also in Blog

    LIGHTER CHICKEN MARSALA
    LIGHTER CHICKEN MARSALA

    September 28, 2022

    This Lighter Chicken Marsala is a macro-friendly take on my favorite Italian-American dish. It satisfies in every way! The fork-tender chicken filets are smothered in rich marsala sauce with mushrooms, perfect over a bed of buttery noodles. It's also low-fat, low-carb, high-protein, gluten-free and dairy-free! An absolutely flavorful dish that tastes even better as leftovers.

    View full article →

    PUMPKIN CHIP PROTEIN BREAD (GLUTEN FREE, DAIRY FREE)
    PUMPKIN CHIP PROTEIN BREAD (GLUTEN FREE, DAIRY FREE)

    September 24, 2022

    This Pumpkin Chip Protein Bread has a rich, tender texture full of pumpkin spice and chocolate chips (no dry protein bread here). The kids and I can't get enough! Best of all, it's gluten-free, dairy-free, nut-free and easily made egg-free and vegan.

     

    View full article →

    PROTEIN APPLE CRISP (DAIRY FREE)
    PROTEIN APPLE CRISP (DAIRY FREE)

    September 14, 2022

    Apple desserts have to be my favorite - and this Protein Apple Crisp did not disappoint! Baked cinnamon apples are layered between two buttery layers of oat crisp, with a hint of cardamom for those "apple pie" vibes. It's the perfect healthy dessert topped with your choice of dairy-free or protein vanilla ice cream! 

    View full article →

    Get my FREE meal prep guide!

    Get family-friendly recipes, nutrition tips and faith-based inspiration delivered straight to your inbox.